clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile
A highball cocktail on a blonde bar.
The “From One Hustler to Another” cocktail from Another Country.
Max Flatlow/Another Country

The Hottest New Bars in New York City, May 2024

A listening bar and an Italian-inspired cocktail spot join the list this month

View as Map
The “From One Hustler to Another” cocktail from Another Country.
| Max Flatlow/Another Country

Welcome to the Bars Heatmap, a guide to the hottest places to grab a dirty martini in New York City right now. After subsisting on takeout drinks served from plastic cups for the first year of the pandemic, the city’s cocktail and dive bars are back in full swing, reinventing classics and cashing in on nostalgia.

New to the list in April: Union Square listening bar, Another Country; and Italian-leaning cocktails and small plates from L’Americana join the list in May.

For more New York dining recommendations, check out the new hotspots in Brooklyn and Queens. And for an insider’s perspective on how to eat well no matter where you are in NYC, pick up our new book: The Eater Guide to New York City.

Read More
Eater maps are curated by editors and aim to reflect a diversity of neighborhoods, cuisines, and prices. Learn more about our editorial process. If you buy something or book a reservation from an Eater link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics policy.

Bar Orai

Copy Link

Listening bars are everywhere in New York, but Bar Orai’s location stands out. The space, hidden on the second floor of a Midtown building, is designed like a living room with midcentury couches and armchairs that make it feel low-key and relaxing. Stop by for Japanese whiskey, and listen to songs from the 2,000 vinyl records on its walls. There’s food like katsu sandwiches (the team also owns East Village Japanese restaurant AOI Kitchen). The bar has no website, and reservations are a must.

The listening room of Bar Orai,
Bar Orai is tucked away on the second floor of a Midtown building.
Bar Orai

The Tusk Bar

Copy Link

The Tusk Bar serves smart remixes of cocktails you already know: There’s a play on a Bloody Mary made with soy and Clamato and a martini mixed with shallot vinegar. The food menu comes from the team behind Wildair and includes a shrimp cocktail, chickpea fritters with Thai basil aioli, and a passionfruit pavlova. The bar is part of a trio of projects at the Evelyn Hotel, with a restaurant and cafe to come. It’s quiet here, making it good for meetings, gossiping, or both.

Cocktails with oysters at the Tusk Bar.
Cocktails with oysters at the Tusk Bar.
Eric Medsker/the Tusk Bar

Another Country

Copy Link

Housed in a “moody, cozy space” in what had been the newer location of the stalwart diner, Chat ‘N Chew, Another Country is a listening bar named for the 1962 James Baldwin novel. The food menu includes fried peanuts, fried chicken, and a sardine sandwich, while drinks in the $16 to $18 range come with names like “No Room for Squares” that show off mezcal, Campari, Carpano, and mole bitters. It’s owned by Botanica’s Mark Connell (also a current partner in Brooklyn pizzeria Oma Grassa and the Ridgewood bar Nowadays), and DJ and bartender Timothy Jenkins.

A wide angle of a dark bar.
The bar at Another Country.
Max Flatow/Another Country

L'Americana

Copy Link

This Italian-leaning bar in Gramercy comes from Takuma Watanabe of Martiny’s and chef Suchandrima “Suzy” Mukherjee (Boqueria & Benoit). Look for over a dozen cocktails on a menu from Italian-native Nicolò Amadori, along with small plates like pickled mussels and ’nduja or black arancini octopus.

Sip & Guzzle

Copy Link

Sip & Guzzle is two destinations in one. The lower level of the bar, called Sip, is run by Shingo Gokan: Before opening eight bars across Japan and China, Gokan had been the bar director for a decade at Angel’s Share in Manhattan, which opened in 1993, closed, then reopened in July. The upper level, named Guzzle, is overseen by Employees Only alum Steve Schneider; he serves classics and more familiar cocktails, plus swanky izakaya fare and Japanese street food from Mike Bagale, former chef of three-Michelin-starred Alinea in Chicago.

Inside a dark lair for drinking.
Inside the lower level, Sip, at Sip & Guzzle.
Sasha Arutyunova/Sip & Guzzle

Bar Nena

Copy Link

Mexican cocktails are finally getting their due. New bars like Superbueno and Lolita have been putting smoky, salty drinks in the spotlight. Bar Nena is another one to watch. The West Village bar from the owners of Jajaja serves mixed Mexican drinks, like carajillos and micheladas, plus fermented beverages, like pulque and tepache. The small food menu has Mexican deviled eggs, chicharrones, and chorizo tacos.

A yellow cocktail with pebble ice sits on the counter of a bar.
The Ni Maiz, with mezcal, lemongrass, pineapple, and lemon.
Ricardo Escalante/Bar Nena

The Lions Bar & Grill

Copy Link

The team behind the Lions knows what they’re doing on the cocktail front, also running cocktail bar and tavern, Goodnight Sonny; music venue the Wayland; and Madeline’s Martini, all in the East Village. The Lions has ambitions to be more than just a hangout for drinks, with a standout menu outfitted with magnificent mortadella sandwiches, burgers, triangular mozzarella sticks, and more. It’s a really solid after-work option.

A mortadella sandwich on a plate with chips.
The mortadella sandwich is the move.
The Lions

Superbueno

Copy Link

This Mexican cocktail bar is run by a former employee of Ghost Donkey, a popular bar in the East Village that closed during the pandemic. The bar stays open until 2 a.m. or later every night with a rowdy crowd that chases mezcal shots with beef consomé. Cocktails, like a green mango martini and a salted tamarind milk punch, start at around $20.

The pink-lit bar at Superbueno.
The bar at Superbueno.
Superbueno

William Elliott, bar director at sibling location, Maison Premiere, oversees the beverage menu at Tigre, which pulled ideas from Playboy’s Host & Bar Book. Cocktails have names like the Rolls Royce and Mister Softee. The space features a horseshoe-shaped bar that evokes “residential sexiness in New York from the 1970s, ’80s, and maybe even ’90s,” according to New York Magazine.

Inside a dark, swanky bar.
Inside Tigre from the folks behind Maison Premiere.
Eric Medsker/Tigre

Hellbender Nighttime Café

Copy Link

Is anyone surprised that Hellbender is a hit? The new cocktail bar, from the owners of the American restaurant, Rolo’s, has customers lining up for carajillos and margaritas in a dining room with booth seating and a stuffed jaguar. Hellbender is a bar, but you could also treat it like a restaurant: There’s a full food menu with fried fish sandwiches, queso fundido, shrimp cocktail, and more.

A fried fish sandwich with cilantro mayo.
Hellbender serves a full food menu, too.
Lanna Apisukh/Eater NY

Bar Orai

Listening bars are everywhere in New York, but Bar Orai’s location stands out. The space, hidden on the second floor of a Midtown building, is designed like a living room with midcentury couches and armchairs that make it feel low-key and relaxing. Stop by for Japanese whiskey, and listen to songs from the 2,000 vinyl records on its walls. There’s food like katsu sandwiches (the team also owns East Village Japanese restaurant AOI Kitchen). The bar has no website, and reservations are a must.

The listening room of Bar Orai,
Bar Orai is tucked away on the second floor of a Midtown building.
Bar Orai

The Tusk Bar

The Tusk Bar serves smart remixes of cocktails you already know: There’s a play on a Bloody Mary made with soy and Clamato and a martini mixed with shallot vinegar. The food menu comes from the team behind Wildair and includes a shrimp cocktail, chickpea fritters with Thai basil aioli, and a passionfruit pavlova. The bar is part of a trio of projects at the Evelyn Hotel, with a restaurant and cafe to come. It’s quiet here, making it good for meetings, gossiping, or both.

Cocktails with oysters at the Tusk Bar.
Cocktails with oysters at the Tusk Bar.
Eric Medsker/the Tusk Bar

Another Country

Housed in a “moody, cozy space” in what had been the newer location of the stalwart diner, Chat ‘N Chew, Another Country is a listening bar named for the 1962 James Baldwin novel. The food menu includes fried peanuts, fried chicken, and a sardine sandwich, while drinks in the $16 to $18 range come with names like “No Room for Squares” that show off mezcal, Campari, Carpano, and mole bitters. It’s owned by Botanica’s Mark Connell (also a current partner in Brooklyn pizzeria Oma Grassa and the Ridgewood bar Nowadays), and DJ and bartender Timothy Jenkins.

A wide angle of a dark bar.
The bar at Another Country.
Max Flatow/Another Country

L'Americana

This Italian-leaning bar in Gramercy comes from Takuma Watanabe of Martiny’s and chef Suchandrima “Suzy” Mukherjee (Boqueria & Benoit). Look for over a dozen cocktails on a menu from Italian-native Nicolò Amadori, along with small plates like pickled mussels and ’nduja or black arancini octopus.

Sip & Guzzle

Sip & Guzzle is two destinations in one. The lower level of the bar, called Sip, is run by Shingo Gokan: Before opening eight bars across Japan and China, Gokan had been the bar director for a decade at Angel’s Share in Manhattan, which opened in 1993, closed, then reopened in July. The upper level, named Guzzle, is overseen by Employees Only alum Steve Schneider; he serves classics and more familiar cocktails, plus swanky izakaya fare and Japanese street food from Mike Bagale, former chef of three-Michelin-starred Alinea in Chicago.

Inside a dark lair for drinking.
Inside the lower level, Sip, at Sip & Guzzle.
Sasha Arutyunova/Sip & Guzzle

Bar Nena

Mexican cocktails are finally getting their due. New bars like Superbueno and Lolita have been putting smoky, salty drinks in the spotlight. Bar Nena is another one to watch. The West Village bar from the owners of Jajaja serves mixed Mexican drinks, like carajillos and micheladas, plus fermented beverages, like pulque and tepache. The small food menu has Mexican deviled eggs, chicharrones, and chorizo tacos.

A yellow cocktail with pebble ice sits on the counter of a bar.
The Ni Maiz, with mezcal, lemongrass, pineapple, and lemon.
Ricardo Escalante/Bar Nena

The Lions Bar & Grill

The team behind the Lions knows what they’re doing on the cocktail front, also running cocktail bar and tavern, Goodnight Sonny; music venue the Wayland; and Madeline’s Martini, all in the East Village. The Lions has ambitions to be more than just a hangout for drinks, with a standout menu outfitted with magnificent mortadella sandwiches, burgers, triangular mozzarella sticks, and more. It’s a really solid after-work option.

A mortadella sandwich on a plate with chips.
The mortadella sandwich is the move.
The Lions

Superbueno

This Mexican cocktail bar is run by a former employee of Ghost Donkey, a popular bar in the East Village that closed during the pandemic. The bar stays open until 2 a.m. or later every night with a rowdy crowd that chases mezcal shots with beef consomé. Cocktails, like a green mango martini and a salted tamarind milk punch, start at around $20.

The pink-lit bar at Superbueno.
The bar at Superbueno.
Superbueno

Tigre

William Elliott, bar director at sibling location, Maison Premiere, oversees the beverage menu at Tigre, which pulled ideas from Playboy’s Host & Bar Book. Cocktails have names like the Rolls Royce and Mister Softee. The space features a horseshoe-shaped bar that evokes “residential sexiness in New York from the 1970s, ’80s, and maybe even ’90s,” according to New York Magazine.

Inside a dark, swanky bar.
Inside Tigre from the folks behind Maison Premiere.
Eric Medsker/Tigre

Hellbender Nighttime Café

Is anyone surprised that Hellbender is a hit? The new cocktail bar, from the owners of the American restaurant, Rolo’s, has customers lining up for carajillos and margaritas in a dining room with booth seating and a stuffed jaguar. Hellbender is a bar, but you could also treat it like a restaurant: There’s a full food menu with fried fish sandwiches, queso fundido, shrimp cocktail, and more.

A fried fish sandwich with cilantro mayo.
Hellbender serves a full food menu, too.
Lanna Apisukh/Eater NY

Related Maps